Who Is PicRights and Should You Pay Their Demand?
The more things change, the more they stay the same.
For a very long time, people have enjoyed a certain level of protection for their intellectual property. Things like patents and copyright exist to allow you to create without the fear of your creations being stolen… or at least to give you an avenue for the recovery of damages if they are.
For nearly as long as these rights have existed, there have been people and companies that seek to weaponize them. It wasn't until around the early 2000s, though, that they were given a name: trolls.
I'm not just talking about the people leaving insulting comments on YouTube videos here. Copyright and Patent Trolls are a kind of entity that operates in a legal gray area. There's some legitimacy to what they do, which is why it's impossible to simply ignore them outright.
PicRights is a name you're likely seeing going around. Maybe you've even gotten a letter from them yourself. They're the latest in a long line of companies like Righthaven, Visual Rights Group, Strike 3, Copytrack, and even Prenda Law. They aren't new (they've been around doing this for at least five years), but there has been a significant surge recently, so it's worth talking about both the concept of the copyright troll in general, and PicRights in specific.
How it Happens
Picture this.
Today is a day like any other. You woke up, had your coffee, ate a little breakfast, and settled in for work. Around lunch, you take a break, grab another bite to eat, and check your mail.
On top of the stack is one from this company you've never heard of before. You open it, and inside is a threat.
According to this letter, PicRights has detected an image on your website. It's a photo, something you posted as part of a blog post, possibly years ago, so long ago you barely even remember it.
According to this letter, the image in question is the intellectual property of their client. It might be the Associated Press. It might be Reuters. It might be some European news or stock photo agency you've never even heard of.
According to this letter, your use of the image is unsanctioned and unlicensed.
According to this letter, due to your use of the image, you're liable for damages for copyright violation. The number is shocking; $1,700, $3,200, some other huge fee for a png file.
If you don't pay, they threaten to sue, to take you to court to get their damages, usually an even higher fee than the one they're offering now. Numbers like $30k and $100k are not uncommon.
Your day is ruined, and that's just the start. Now what?
How it Works
So, what's happening here?
Companies like PicRights call themselves "copyright enforcement and claims resolution specialists".
The idea is that big entities like Reuters or AP create many thousands of images every year. Copyright is automatic, and the protection applies the moment a piece of intellectual property is created. But companies like Reuters don't have the time, the employees, or the funds to bother enforcing most of that copyright. So, the images they create can end up taken and reused.
It's also tricky to track who is able to use the images. Some stories are syndicated across thousands of websites, and all of them, due to the syndication, have the right to use the images. Some people go out of their way to pay to license the images, particularly when they're stock photos. Others can claim fair use, which is a complex topic of its own that I'm not going to dig too deep into.
So, a company like PicRights steps in. They say "hey, Reuters, we'll scan the internet, look for violations of your copyright, and handle claims on your behalf. We hand you most of the damages we recover, keeping some for our own fees, and you don't need to do anything." Reuters, or the AP, or whoever else, agrees and signs the contract.
Once the ink is dried, PicRights sends out their legion of web crawlers and bots to scan the internet looking for any case where an image that their client owns has been used on another site. When they find it, they identify the contact information for the site and send their letter, as outlined above.
They provide all the information you need to give them money right away and settle a claim. If you don't want to settle, like you believe you have a fair use defense or you know you licensed the image, well, it's somewhat more difficult to contact them about this.
If you respond and pay immediately, the claim goes away. That doesn't protect you from future claims on other images, though, and once they've identified that you pay, there's a decent chance they're going to look a little harder at your domain.
If you respond and fight, the process gets messy. They might send back more proof, or they might not. They might send back generic statements about how copyright works. They might take your refutations and accept them, and drop the claim. They might just never respond.
If you ignore them, things escalate. They'll send an increasingly threatening set of letters over the course of several months, and eventually refer to their partner law firm, which can then actually take you to court.
What Makes a Copyright Troll a Scam?
That's the tricky thing: they aren't, technically speaking, a scam at all.
What they are is a threat, with a high-pressure and aggressive set of techniques, to scare people into paying when they might not actually have to.
This is where it gets difficult to discuss this topic, because speaking definitively about how these companies operate can itself be a liability. But, examining some of the past historical precedent and the actions of now-defunct companies doing similar things, some trends emerge.
- They may not always have the full rights they claim to be enforcing.
- They may issue a threat for images that are fair use or legally licensed.
- They may identify images that aren't actually the right images, because bot image recognition isn't perfect.
Copyright trolls have sent threat letters in the past for public domain images, images they don't have the rights to, and even images that aren't actually the ones they've identified.
The trouble here is that almost all of this is fully automated. Everything from the reverse image searching to the case generation to the follow-ups are formulaic and automatic.
This is because copyright trolls rely on sheer volume. Even if 90% of the people they send letters to ignore them, and 5% fight back and the claim is dropped, it doesn't matter. If 5% of people pay, that's still a profit. When they're sending out thousands of these every day, it doesn't take much to pull in the money.
Should You Pay? How to Respond to PicRights Letters
Before I get into a specific response protocol here, I need to make one thing clear: I am not a lawyer, and this is not legal advice. If you're worried on the legal front or want to challenge all of this in a court, talk to a real lawyer; don't just follow the advice of a random blog online. There are a handful of law firms out there that specialize in copyright defense and fighting copyright trolls, and you can probably find one in your region by searching for PicRights defense or a similar query.
Should you pay? Not right away. If someone you barely remember walks up to you in the street and says you owe them $20, you're not going to give them $20 unless you have a good reason to, right?
Here's what you should do.
Step 1: Preserve and Gather Evidence
Most people leap to deleting the image, but that's the wrong move. PicRights has already saved a cached version of your page, everything they would need to hand over to their law firm. If you delete the image, all you're doing is depriving yourself of data that could be useful in your own defense.
You may, however, want to replace the image in your live blog (with something you know you have the rights to, of course), and/or unpublish the post it's on.
Gather evidence. Record data like when you published the image, the EXIF metadata for the image, the dimensions of the image, anything you have that could help.
While you're at it, dig into the details of the image. Consider questions like:
- Do you know where you got the image from in the first place?
- Do you know if you paid to license the image, such as from a stock photo website or Canva?
- Did you get the image from a third party, like a graphic designer or content creator you hired freelance?
- Is the image in the public domain or released under a Creative Commons or other royalty-free license?
Answering these questions can inform you whether or not you have an adequate defense or a legitimate liability.
Step 2: Request Proof and Details
Instead of paying, even if you think you're legitimately in violation, take the time to respond and demand verification of the claim. Ask for proof that the rightsholder actually holds the rights and that PicRights has the right to pursue the claim. Ask for the copyright registration number.
What is a copyright registration number? Well, the US Copyright Office allows you to file for a copyright registration on a piece of content you create. It's not mandatory for protection (imagine if you had to file a form for every blog post you wrote or picture you took!), but it is mandatory to sue someone over it. If PicRights has that number already, then it's an image they've probably already sued over. If they don't, it at minimum gives you more runway while they file before suing.
You can also look up the number, if they give it to you, to validate that it's actually what they claim it is. There's some chance that it isn't. That said, it can be costly to file a request with the copyright office on your own; this is also something you probably want to work with a law firm over.
But hey, it's better to pay the copyright office $400 than it is to pay PicRights $3,000, right?
Now, if you have a legitimate defense and can back it up, like proof of licensing for the image or proof the image is public domain, you can respond with that and get the claim to go away. This, too, is something you probably want a law firm to handle for you, since if you say the wrong thing, they can use it against you.
Step 3: Audit Your Site
While you're dealing with all of this, or while your law firm is, you want to do a deep dive on your site. Look for any possible image that could potentially have a similar claim filed against it. Replace these, keeping the originals around in case another claim comes in later. Remember, they have likely cached your site already, but may not have processed all the claims they would want to.
From here, what you do all depends on how your defense is built.
How a PicRights Letter is Resolved
There are a handful of possible outcomes for one of these letters.
If you have a good case, either because you have a valid use case or license, or because PicRights doesn't have the rights they claim to have, you can usually get out of the claim. This doesn't protect you from other claims, though, and nothing stops them from scanning your site for anything else they think can trigger a better claim.
If you don't have a good defense and you're legitimately in violation, you can attempt to negotiate for a lower settlement. Be very careful with anything of this sort; the moment you admit to a violation, they have you on the hook. Definitely have a lawyer involved if this is the case. You might still be able to get out of it if PicRights doesn't have all the information, or you might have to pay.
Some ways that claims can be lowered is by arguing a different use for the image than what they allege. PicRights will go for the highest possible settlement claim citing premium commercial use; if your use is more limited, noncommercial, educational, or otherwise restricted, the claim can be lower.
If you fight back and they double down, there's a chance the claim can be escalated to their law firm. In that case, it's a waiting game. Reportedly, a lot of the time, when they say they're escalating, that's the end of it; the law firm either sends one basic form letter and then drops it, or it just never gets passed on. Many people report reaching this point and never hearing another word from them.
After all, it's expensive for these entities to actually go to court. Their goal is to get settlements, not win lawsuits.
That said, they do file enough lawsuits to keep the threat alive. Even if only 1 out of 1,000 claims goes to court, you don't want to be that one.
So, should you pay PicRights? Maybe, but only after extensive defensive action and talking to a law firm about it. Ideally, you'll be able to pay a law firm a lot less than the claim would be and make it all go away.
Take it seriously, but don't panic, and don't admit to anything. Consult a lawyer to get things right.
